Repair or Replace a Refrigerator?

Most refrigerator problems come down to one failed part. Here is how we help you decide, with real numbers, before any work begins.

$0 Diagnostic with Repair Our $109 service call is credited toward your repair when you approve it.

Average repair costs less than $300

The short answer

Diagnose first. A refrigerator that is warm, noisy or leaking usually has one failed part behind it, and a single part on an otherwise sound refrigerator is normally worth repairing.

Our $109 service call covers the visit and diagnosis and is credited toward your repair when you approve it. You get the exact repair price after diagnosis, before any work begins, and you compare that number with the price of a comparable new refrigerator. If the diagnosis points the other way, we tell you.

Refrigerator compressor close-up during a diagnosis

Repair vs. replace at a glance

How repairing compares with replacing a refrigerator. Prices are never guessed: the repair side is quoted after diagnosis, the replace side is the price of a comparable new refrigerator.
FactorRepairReplace
Cost to find out$109 service call, which covers the visit and diagnosis and is credited toward the repair when you approve it.The price of a comparable new refrigerator.
What the price is based onThe part that failed and the labor to replace it, quoted after diagnosis and before any work begins.The model you choose: size, features and finish set the price, not the fault.
Installation and fitThe refrigerator stays in its cutout with its water line, finish and handles unchanged.A new unit has to fit the cutout, the doorway and the water line; built-in, counter-depth and French-door models are the hardest to match.
How many major parts have failedOne failed part on an otherwise sound refrigerator is a normal repair.Several major components failing at the same time make a repair harder to justify.
Parts availabilityA part we can get is a repair we can quote.Parts that are discontinued or on a long backorder tip the decision toward replacing.
Warranty60-day parts and labor warranty on the completed repair.Whatever warranty comes with the new unit.

What to weigh before you decide

  • What failed. One part (a defrost heater or thermostat, a fan motor, a start relay, a door gasket or a water valve) is the normal case. Several major components at once is not.
  • Food at risk. A refrigerator that has stopped cooling needs a decision today. Book the diagnosis, then decide with the quote in hand instead of guessing.
  • Fit. Built-in, counter-depth and French-door models are matched to a kitchen cutout and a water line. A replacement has to fit the same space.
  • The quote against the price of a comparable new refrigerator. We give you the exact repair price after diagnosis so the comparison is real.
  • Parts availability for your model. Discontinued parts or a long backorder change the answer.
Customer giving a thumbs-up beside a French-door refrigerator

Usually worth diagnosing and repairing

These are the everyday refrigerator repairs: one failed part, replaced on site, with the refrigerator staying where it is.

  • A refrigerator not cooling while the compressor runs: usually a defrost heater or defrost thermostat, an evaporator or condenser fan motor, a damper or a temperature sensor.
  • A failed compressor start relay or capacitor on an otherwise sound refrigerator.
  • A fridge leaking water or water under the crisper drawers: a defrost drain tube, a water inlet valve or a filter housing.
  • An ice maker not making ice or a water dispenser not working on a refrigerator that otherwise works.
  • A freezer not freezing while the fresh-food side holds temperature.
  • A fridge making noise from a fan motor, or a door gasket, hinge, crisper track or leveling problem.
  • A built-in, counter-depth or French-door model that fits your kitchen cutout.

When replacement may make more sense

  • Several major components are failing at the same time.
  • The repair quote comes close to the price of a comparable new refrigerator.
  • Parts for your model are discontinued or on a long backorder.

If the diagnosis points to the sealed system (the compressor and refrigerant circuit), we explain what we found and what your options are before anything is quoted or done. Either way, you decide with the facts in front of you.

What it costs to find out

Our $109 service call covers the visit and diagnosis and is credited toward your repair when you approve it. You get the exact repair price after diagnosis, before any work begins.

Typical total repair cost (parts + labor): $150–$500

Estimated labor by repair group on our refrigerator repair page, labor only, parts extra: Controls & sensors $99–$249; Parts & mechanical $99–$249. Parts are quoted separately after diagnosis.

Examples of estimated labor by repair (labor only, parts extra)
RepairEstimated labor (parts extra)
Defrost thermostat replacement$179–$249
Evaporator fan motor replacement$199–$249
Compressor start relay or capacitor replacement$179–$249
Door gasket (seal) replacement$199–$249

60-day parts & labor warranty

See the full estimated labor table by repair on our refrigerator repair page. Book online and save $25 on a completed repair.

Ready to find out? Book online or call the number above, and read more about our refrigerator repair in Denver.

Not sure which way to go? Contact us with the model number and the symptom, and we will tell you what the diagnosis involves before you book.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it worth repairing a refrigerator that is not cooling?

Usually yes. A refrigerator that runs but does not cool most often has one failed part: a defrost heater or defrost thermostat, an evaporator or condenser fan motor, a start relay, a damper or a temperature sensor. We replace the part on site and quote the exact repair after diagnosis, before any work begins. If several major components are failing at the same time, we tell you that instead.

How much does it cost to find out whether my refrigerator can be repaired?

Our $109 service call covers the visit and diagnosis and is credited toward your repair when you approve it. You get the exact repair price before any work begins, so you can compare it with the price of a comparable new refrigerator and decide.

What does refrigerator repair cost in Denver?

Typical total repair cost (parts + labor) is $150–$500 on our refrigerator repair page, depending on the part. The estimated labor by repair is listed there as labor only, parts extra, and every completed repair carries our 60-day parts and labor warranty.

Does a built-in, counter-depth or French-door refrigerator change the decision?

Yes. Those models are matched to a kitchen cutout and a water line, so a replacement has to fit the same space and finish. A single failed part on a built-in, counter-depth or French-door refrigerator is normally worth repairing.

What if only the freezer or the ice maker is the problem?

A freezer compartment that will not freeze or an ice maker that has stopped on a refrigerator that otherwise works is normally a repair, not a replacement. See our freezer repair and ice maker repair pages for those faults.

More Repair-or-Replace Guides

Refrigerator Troubleshooting Guides

← Back to Refrigerator Repair

Need Help Deciding?

A diagnosis gives you the exact repair price before any work begins, so you can compare it with the price of a comparable new appliance.

Call Now Book Online — $25 Off